UTU LOCAL 194 BLACK BOX ADVISORY

A Paper Trail with a UTU Safety Report Leads to Safety

By Mike Futhey International President

REPORT MODIFIED FOR THE SPECIFIC NEEDS OF UTU 194

We have been receiving numerous reports of members disciplined following an on-the-job
injury. Too often, the injury was the result of a carrier’s failure to correct its own safety hazard
or safety violation. But if there is no paper trail of the safety hazard or carrier safety violation
prior to the injury, the injured employee can end up becoming a victim for a second time
through discipline. How do you keep from becoming a victim twice? You write a detailed
letter describing every safety hazard and every violation of FRA safety regulations
encountered. Blank UTU Safety Report Forms for that purpose are available at the Elkhart
Crew Rooms. Send that report to any UTU Local 194 Officer. Your Safety complaint will be
forwarded to the Carrier Safety Committee Members and to the State Legislative Office for
follow-up if necessary. Even though, retaliation against the member is prohibited by law, your
name will not be attached when filing the report. Your Local Chairman will TAKE THE HEAT
from the unhappy carrier officials. We urge any and all employees to use these life and injury
saving reports. You don’t have to belong to UTU 194 or the even the UTU. The Safety
problem should be reported for any location where you work, such as other Divisions, other
Terminals or even other Railroads.  By so doing, you have created a paper trail, preventing
the carrier from later disavowing knowledge of the safety hazard or safety violation.Just a
few examples of unsafe conditions or safety hazards are, any condition that could cause an
injury, death or accident including unsafe or unstable walking conditions such as loose
ballast, uneven surface, standing water, mud, oil, grease, loose sand, unexpected ice
accumulations, debris, construction material, faulty equipment, close clearances, any orders
to perform unsafe tasks and thousands of others. The carriers are required to provide you a
safe place to work. Often they neglect a problem they  may be aware of because it cost to
much or it is inconvenient to repair. When you report an unsafe condition, the carrier is put on
notice of that fact. We need to refuse to allow unsafe conditions to exist. These safety reports
help to keep our people safe and alive.Beyond protecting yourself against arbitrary carrier
discipline following an injury, here are three other reasons why you should write that detailed
letter: •The Federal Railroad Administration has a limited number of safety inspectors. They
cannot, on their own, find every carrier safety violation. When state legislative directors
receive copies of your letter to the carrier, they can refer those safety violations to the
appropriate FRA official. By collecting those letters, state legislative directors can also identify
multiple violations that should be reported to the national legislative office for handling at the
highest levels of the FRA. •State legislative directors work with lawmakers at the state and
federal level to craft legislation leading to new and improved safety regulations. In Illinois, for
example, State Legislative Director Joe Szabo convinced the legislature to pass a rail-safety
bill based on evidence presented by UTU members about safety hazards. The current federal
rail safety bill being considered by Congress includes provisions that would not have been
embraced by lawmakers were it not for written evidence provided by UTU members. •When
employees are injured, and they seek recovery under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, it is
not uncommon for the carrier to deny knowledge of the safety hazard or its own violation of
safety regulations. But when local legislative representatives and state legislative directors
can provide UTU Designated Legal Counsel with copies of such letters, your legal case is
strengthened. Simply calling a carrier’s safety hotline is not enough to protect you, your family
or your brothers and sisters from carrier safety hazards and safety violations. Those
telephone calls go only to the carrier, which may or may not correct the situation. Only when
your local legislative representative and state legislative director receive your letter can they
help you take action to correct the problem and make the workplace safer. If you need help
writing the letter, ask your local legislative representative or state legislative director for that
help. Don’t become a victim twice. Write that letter and make sure a copy goes to your local
legislative representative and your state legislative director.




PRODUCED BY UTU LOCAL 194 INFORMATION & COMMUNICATION SUB-COMMITTEE